26 Comments

Masterful post, well worth the time it took to make it, thank you for this.

Expand full comment
Nov 6, 2023Liked by Peter Nimitz

A wonderful quote from Hesiod and overall an excellent post.

Expand full comment

New reader here, just saying thanks.

Expand full comment
Nov 9, 2023Liked by Peter Nimitz

Excellent essay. Your command over a huge breadth and depth of subjects is apparent.

Any recommendations for books to delve into specifically the spread of the Celtic peoples during this time?

Expand full comment
Nov 6, 2023Liked by Peter Nimitz

Very interesting. I was particularly interested on the P and Q Celtic division and how it affected Britain and Ireland.

Expand full comment

Why did Greeks leave so many written records while the equally sophisticated Anatolians didn't? Same issue with Israelites and Phoenicians and also with the Greeks and Persians. Its crazy to me we get the perspective of a small Greek states but not of the Persian Empire in their wars. Its as if in the wars between Romans and the Britons, its the Britons who left all the written records.

Expand full comment

I found the Cline book pretty dry. He seemed to end up saying Bronze Age collapse was mainly environmental.

I did enjoy learning more about the Hittites which I wasn’t too familiar with.

Expand full comment

I swear I subbed to you before but I was unsubbed when I got this article recommended. I wonder if Substack is doing the YouTube thing where it seemingly randomly unsubscribes users from certain channels.

Expand full comment

Is there any history to the Uralic peoples? After reading that the indo-Aryans were originally slaves to the Uralics I need to know more

Expand full comment

Oh wow! There is literally Ukraine spreading way way into Russia but NO Russia on the Britannica map - what year is it from? Bronze age??? What was the capital of Ukraine then and who was the Tsar? Emperor? Maybe enlighten us with the next post

Expand full comment